I've sampled a third location in my hunt for a cupcake bakery in Monmouth County. I don't want to count my cupcakes before they're baked, but I think I found a slice of heaven.
Location #3 - Chocolate Carousel, Wall
The total cost for 4 cupcakes was $12. The Chocolate Carousel bakery is, so far, the go-to location for delicious cupcakes in Monmouth County.